Affiliate disclosure: Some links may be affiliate links. If you buy through one, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Any paid relationship is identified where it applies. Full disclosure.

This pumpkin coconut eggnog is thick enough to feel like a holiday drink, yet it pours into a glass rather than sitting like pudding. Cooked pumpkin gives the body, homemade coconut milk keeps it dairy-free, and one fresh whole egg makes it an eggnog instead of a pumpkin smoothie. Homemade vanilla, a little mineral salt, raw honey to taste and freshly grated nutmeg finish it.

Two small glasses of thick pumpkin coconut eggnog for Full GAPS with freshly grated nutmeg — Two small servings, lightly topped with freshly grated nutmeg.

As a working, homeschooling mom of six, I appreciate recipes that leave room for the rest of the day. Homeschooling happens before my second shift, and there is plenty to fit around the kitchen. A cold blender drink is a manageable addition to a holiday meal. You can cook the squash ahead, have the homemade milk ready, and do the short blend when you want to serve it. The pumpkin and milk do most of the work here. You are looking for a creamy drink, not another long cooking project.

This cold Full GAPS eggnog makes two small glasses, about six ounces each, or one larger glass. You can use half a cup of cooked pumpkin, or the same amount of cooked butternut or winter squash. Choose the squash you have, then taste before adding honey. That small adjustment lets you keep the drink creamy without making every batch equally sweet.

Choose The Pumpkin And Milk

Measure half a cup of homemade cooked pumpkin purée. Start with fresh pumpkin or squash that you cook and mash at home. A thick, soft purée gives the drink its body without flour, starch or a commercial thickener. It should be cooked through and mashed smooth enough that there are no firm pieces to catch on the blender blade. The color may be deep orange or a little paler depending on the pumpkin. A watery purée will give a thinner drink, so measure the prepared squash rather than adding cooking water with it.

Cooked butternut squash or another winter squash works at the same half-cup measure. Butternut is often sweeter than a mild pumpkin, so it may need less honey. You will make that decision after the first blend. Keep the amount of squash steady, then adjust the sweetness to suit the batch you have made.

Half cup of smooth cooked pumpkin puree for Full GAPS coconut eggnog before blending — Start with a measured half cup of cooked purée that holds a soft spoon track.

Use three-quarters of a cup of homemade additive-free coconut milk. Stir the jar before measuring if a chilled batch has separated. The milk loosens the purée enough to blend while keeping the drink coconut-rich and dairy-free. A canned or sweetened coconut beverage is not the homemade milk specified in this version.

Keep The Whole Egg And Homemade Vanilla

One fresh large whole egg goes into the blender, both yolk and white. Full GAPS includes raw whole eggs in blended shakes. Here, the egg joins the cooked pumpkin and coconut milk in a cold drink. Blend until the egg white has disappeared into the mixture and no clear streaks remain. You do not need to separate the egg or cook a custard for this version.

Add one teaspoon of homemade GAPS vanilla extract. Regular homemade vanilla works with the coconut and nutmeg. It softens the earthy edge of the pumpkin without needing a vanilla syrup or extra sweetener. The linked recipe gives you homemade vanilla to keep on hand for drinks and baking.

Add a small pinch of mineral salt with the milk, pumpkin, egg and vanilla. It should bring the flavors together without making the drink taste salty. Start small. You will taste the eggnog after blending, when the pumpkin, coconut and vanilla have combined and you can decide how much honey to add.

Blend Until Even And Pourable

Put the homemade coconut milk, cooked pumpkin, whole egg, vanilla and salt into the blender. I use the Ninja BN801. Its 72-ounce pitcher has plenty of room for this small batch, so the mixture sits near the bottom. Keep the recipe proportions steady even though the pitcher can hold much more. Choose the batch size by how many glasses you want to serve.

Blend for one to two minutes, stopping only after the mixture is one even muted pumpkin-gold color. You should not see a white ring of coconut milk, dark orange clumps of purée or streaks of clear egg white. The surface will look creamy with tiny natural pumpkin fibers. Lift a spoonful: it should pour back in a slow ribbon rather than fall in a solid lump. That is the thick eggnog texture the pumpkin supplies.

Full GAPS pumpkin coconut eggnog around coated blades in a Ninja BN801 pitcher after blending — This small batch sits near the bottom of the pitcher. Blend until the color and texture are even.

Give the cooked pumpkin enough time to blend before deciding that the drink needs more milk. Remaining orange lumps mean the purée needs more blending. Start with smooth, fully cooked squash and watch for an even color throughout the pitcher. This batch should be thick and drinkable. Adding extra milk too early can turn it into a thinner pumpkin drink.

Sweeten After Blending

Taste the eggnog before adding honey. Use up to two tablespoons when the pumpkin has very little sweetness; a sweet butternut squash may need less. Add raw honey a little at a time, blend briefly and taste again. Stop when you can still taste pumpkin, coconut and vanilla. Maple syrup is not the GAPS sweetener in this recipe.

After the first small addition of honey, taste a spoonful. You should still notice pumpkin, coconut and vanilla underneath the sweetness. When it tastes balanced to you, stop adding honey. There is no need to use all two tablespoons simply because that upper amount is listed in the card.

Pour the blended eggnog into two small serving glasses or one larger ordinary glass. Grate a little fresh nutmeg directly over the top. A few irregular brown flecks are enough; it should not wear a thick brown crust of spice. Serve it cold. The eggnog should remain creamy and pourable in the glass, with no need for ice cubes, whipped cream or a cinnamon stick.

Where It Fits On GAPS

This drink fits Full GAPS and is already dairy-free. It uses cooked squash, homemade coconut milk, a whole egg, homemade vanilla, raw honey and nutmeg. Save the finished drink for Full GAPS rather than choosing its stage based on the cooked pumpkin alone. The half-cup option of butternut or winter squash keeps the same method and gives you a seasonal choice.

Homemade coconut milk matters here. Use milk you make without additives rather than assuming a can or carton with stabilizers is the same ingredient. The homemade coconut milk recipe gives you the measured ingredient for this eggnog.

The whole egg belongs in this recipe. The pumpkin thickens the drink, but removing the egg would give you a pumpkin-coconut smoothie instead of this eggnog. The yolk and white blend together with the milk and cooked squash. Keep the full egg and use the smooth, uniform appearance as your cue that it has mixed through.

Make It Fresh And Serve Cold

Cook and purée the pumpkin or squash ahead if that helps your kitchen rhythm. Keep the prepared purée and homemade milk ready, then blend the drink when you want to serve it. The active blending takes one to two minutes; add a little time to measure, taste and grate nutmeg. This is not a cooked stovetop custard or a simmered eggnog.

Because the egg goes in raw, prepare the drink for the serving at hand. If it sits briefly before serving, stir it so any settling pumpkin fibers return to the drink. Use a clean glass and grate the nutmeg just before it reaches the table. The best texture is the freshly blended thick ribbon.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Use Butternut Squash Instead Of Pumpkin?

Yes. Use the same measured half cup of cooked butternut or another winter squash. Butternut may be sweeter, so taste before adding honey and stop when the drink tastes right.

Why Is There A Whole Egg?

One large whole egg makes this an eggnog. Blend it with the milk and squash for one to two minutes until the drink has no visible white streaks. A yolk-only or egg-free drink would be a different recipe.

How Much Honey Is Needed?

Use up to two tablespoons raw honey for the batch, and less when the squash is naturally sweet. Add it after the first blend, a little at a time. Taste before deciding whether the full amount belongs in your glass.

Can I Use Store-Bought Coconut Milk?

Use homemade coconut milk for this Full GAPS recipe. GAPS excludes canned coconut milk. Making the milk yourself also keeps added sweeteners and stabilizers out of the drink. Stir any separated coconut cream back into the jar before measuring.

Does The Vanilla Need Bourbon?

No. Use your homemade GAPS vanilla extract. You do not need a special bourbon flavor to make the pumpkin and nutmeg work together. Vanilla syrup would also add sweetness that this recipe handles separately with raw honey.

Can I Make It Hot?

This is a cold blender recipe. Heating it would change the method because the egg would begin to cook. For a warm drink, use the separate Hot Pumpkin Spice Eggnog recipe and follow its cooking directions.

Equipment For Pumpkin Eggnog

Use measuring cups and spoons for the squash and vanilla, and a glass measuring jug for the milk. You also need a blender, a fine grater for the nutmeg, and two small glasses or one larger glass. My Ninja BN801 handles the short blend. Watch the mixture become smooth rather than adding ingredients to fill the pitcher.

If you need more servings, use the scaling control in the card to keep the milk, squash, eggs and vanilla in proportion. Continue adding honey to taste after blending. Choose your batch size by the number of glasses you want to serve, rather than the size of the blender pitcher.

More GAPS Holiday Drinks

The light coconut milk eggnog is a different, thinner coconut drink when you do not want pumpkin thickness. You can also make the homemade vanilla used here ahead of time. The planned WFLI Drinks Cookbook will gather more family-size and single-serving options; check the shop for release details.

Thick Pumpkin Coconut Eggnog Recipe