Homemade vanilla extract gives you a dark, fragrant pantry staple from vanilla beans and plain grape vodka. The work is short: split the pods, collect the seeds, measure the spirit, and close the jars. Then give the vanilla eight weeks in a dark cupboard before using it by the teaspoon in your Full GAPS recipes.
This batch uses thirty-two vanilla beans and one-half US gallon of vodka. That is eight US cups of spirit, with four beans for each cup. The photographs show the batch divided between two glass jars so the pods have room and the lids close comfortably.
When our family started GAPS in July 2024, we had to change much more than what went on the dinner plate. Everyday ingredients mattered too. A flavoring used in a small amount can still have an ingredient list worth reading. Homemade vanilla makes that part straightforward: you choose the whole beans and the plain spirit yourself.
Working second shift and homeschooling before work means I appreciate knowing which kitchen jobs need attention now and which mostly need time. Vanilla falls into the second group. It needs a dated start, a place in the cupboard, and a shake every few days. If you want it ready for holiday baking, start well before the week you need it.
Vanilla Beans And Grape Vodka
Use whole vanilla beans for this recipe. The pods can be wrinkled and dark, with a softer interior that holds the tiny seeds. Splitting them exposes that interior to the spirit. Both the seeds and the pod go into the jar; do not scrape the seeds out and throw the pods away.
Count thirty-two beans for the complete batch. This is a bean-count recipe, so the size and moisture of the pods can affect the strength you get. Use reasonably similar beans within your batch. Four beans per cup gives you a clear starting ratio while the variety brings its own aroma.
For a stronger batch with twice as many beans per cup, see the double-fold homemade vanilla extract. Both versions steep for eight weeks.
Choose plain, unflavored grape vodka with no added sugar, coloring, glycerin, or other additives. It needs to be at least eighty proof, or forty percent alcohol by volume, for this extraction method. A flavored spirit changes what goes into the jar and the flavor of the finished vanilla. Read the product information rather than choosing by the front label alone.
Measure the full one-half US gallon before starting. Do not fill a jar to an arbitrary line and assume the beans and liquid have the right ratio. Vanilla beans take up space too. A container holding exactly eight cups to its brim will not also have comfortable room for all the pods and shaking.
Choosing The Vanilla Flavor
Madagascar Bourbon vanilla is a familiar choice with a sweet, creamy aroma. The word Bourbon in the bean name does not mean you need bourbon whiskey. This recipe uses grape vodka, allowing the bean’s character to lead rather than adding the flavor of a different spirit.
Mexican vanilla brings earthy, woody notes with a little spice. Tahitian vanilla leans floral and can have cherry-like notes. Amadeus’s vanilla guide describes these differences. Use those flavor profiles to choose what you want the vanilla to bring to your baking.
Keep the same bean count and measured grape vodka whichever variety you choose. The variety changes the aroma; it does not change this recipe’s quantities or eight-week steep. If you make more than one jar with different varieties, keep a note of which beans you used so you can choose the flavor you want later.
Glass Jars And Simple Tools
You need clean glass containers with tight lids, a stable board, a small knife or kitchen scissors, a spoon for scraping, and a glass liquid measure. There is no cooking pan or blender in this method. The beans are split and steeped, not heated or blended into a paste.
One glass jar with more than two liters of usable capacity can hold the batch with headroom. The photographs use two one-and-a-half-liter jars instead. Put sixteen prepared beans and four US cups of vodka into each. That keeps the complete recipe at thirty-two beans and eight cups, while leaving space above the liquid in both jars.
A tight lid matters when you shake the extract. Close each jar, check that the lid is seated correctly, and shake gently. Use a cupboard where the jars will be easy to find for their occasional shake, with their start date written in your kitchen notes. You do not need to keep opening them.
Making The Vanilla Extract
Split The Pods Lengthwise
Rest a vanilla bean on the board and cut along its length to open it. Kitchen scissors can do the same job. Work steadily through the measured beans. The goal is to expose the interior, not to turn the whole pod into finely chopped pieces.
Inside, the seeds look like a sticky, fine dark paste. They are much smaller than poppy seeds. A used knife can pick up a little of that sticky material as it cuts. Keep the opened beans together so none of the measured pods gets left behind when you move them to the jar.
Keep The Seeds And Pods
Scrape the seed paste into the clean glass jar with a spoon. Add the split pods too. If you are dividing the batch into two jars, divide the beans and their seeds evenly. There should be sixteen beans in each jar before you add its four cups of vodka.
Some tiny seeds will cling to the spoon or opened pod. Move the scraped material into the jar as you work. The finished extract can have visible seed flecks; it does not need to become perfectly clear to be useful in a recipe.
Add The Spirit And Close The Jars
Add the measured vodka and wet all the pods. Keep the beans beneath the liquid as they steep. Close the lid tightly and give the jar a gentle shake. At this fresh stage, the spirit is still clear, with dark pods and little seed flecks visible through it.
The clear mixture is what the second method photo shows. It has just been assembled. The much darker jars in the finished photographs show the later stage; the vanilla does not turn deep brown the moment you add the beans.
Give It Eight Weeks
Put the closed jars in a dark cupboard and shake every few days. The liquid gradually takes on color from the beans. Fine seeds can settle between shakes and move through the liquid again when you shake the jar.
Plan on eight weeks, or fifty-six days, for this batch. At that point the liquid should be good and dark, with a clear vanilla aroma alongside the alcohol. Steeping does not make the extract alcohol-free. Color and aroma help you follow its progress, but they are not reasons to skip the planned steep.
Using Homemade Vanilla On Full GAPS
Use homemade vanilla made without added sugar or non-GAPS additives for Full GAPS recipes that call for it. This is a flavoring ingredient, measured into another dish. It is not an Introduction Diet food or a drink to add to the daily GAPS routine.
Use the teaspoon or tablespoon specified in the recipe you are making. Vanilla adds aroma rather than sweetness, so it does not replace that recipe’s honey. It also does not replace the food itself: a spoonful flavors a custard, cream, shake, or batter without turning a different ingredient into vanilla.
Commercial vanilla syrup, vanilla flavoring, and products with unknown ingredients are different from this two-ingredient preparation. Making it at home lets you keep the contents clear. There is no need to add sweetener or water to this jar.
Storage And Everyday Use
Keep the extract tightly closed in its dark cupboard. Leave the beans immersed as you use it, and close the jar again after measuring what you need. The seeds may settle at the bottom; a gentle shake redistributes them.
The recipe makes a large amount of flavoring compared with the spoonful used in one dessert. You can scale the batch down by keeping four beans for each US cup of vodka. A smaller batch still needs its steeping time. Making less changes the quantity, not the calendar.
When your extract is ready, use it in the strawberry coconut milk shake for vanilla aroma alongside the fruit, or in hot coconut milk eggnog for a warm, creamy drink. Follow each recipe’s measured vanilla amount and GAPS placement.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Bourbon Vanilla Mean Bourbon Whiskey?
No. Madagascar Bourbon describes the vanilla beans. The alcohol used here is plain grape vodka. Read the bean name and the spirit’s ingredients separately.
Can I Use One Jar Instead Of Two?
Yes. Use a glass jar with enough capacity for all eight cups, the beans, and some headroom. The two jars shown simply divide the same batch evenly. Do not reduce the vodka to make it fit a smaller jar.
Do I Throw Away The Scraped Pods?
Put both the scraped seeds and the pods into the spirit. Scraping exposes the interior and separates some seeds; the pod still belongs in the extraction jar.
Why Are There Dark Specks In My Extract?
Those fine specks can be vanilla seeds released from the opened pods. They can settle between shakes. This method includes the seeds, so their presence is expected.
How Do I Double The Batch?
Use sixty-four beans and one US gallon of grape vodka, keeping the same four-beans-per-cup ratio. Use enough glass containers for the doubled quantity. That is twice as much of this recipe; the eight-week steep stays the same.
Planning Homemade Pantry Staples
If you are changing your pantry for GAPS, the planned 5-Day Pantry Makeover Challenge is a useful place to work through those ingredient choices. Find current and upcoming resources in the WFLI shop. Start the vanilla well before you need it, then keep the ready extract with the other ingredients you use by the spoonful.
Homemade Vanilla Extract for Full GAPS
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- Split the vanilla beans lengthwise with a small knife or kitchen scissors to expose the soft interior. Work through the quantity selected in the ingredient list.
- Scrape the fine, sticky seeds into clean glass containers with a spoon. Add the split pods too. For the base batch shown, divide the beans and seeds equally between two 1.5 L glass jars; each receives sixteen beans.
- Add the spirit amount selected in the ingredient list, dividing it evenly if using several jars. The base two-jar batch uses four US cups per jar. Wet and immerse the pods, close the lids tightly, and shake gently. Choose sufficient glass capacity and headroom for the selected batch size.
- Keep the closed jars in a dark cupboard. Shake every few days so settled vanilla seeds move through the liquid again.
- Steep for eight weeks, or fifty-six days. The extract should be good and dark with a distinct vanilla aroma alongside the alcohol. Keep the beans immersed, close tightly after use, and measure the amount specified in the recipe you are making.
Notes
Tried this recipe?
Let us know how it was!
Leave a comment