Hot pumpkin spice eggnog turns a quarter cup of cooked pumpkin into a warm, creamy drink. Two whole eggs give it body, while coconut butter and water make its simple coconut base. Vanilla, honey, and pumpkin pie spice bring the flavor together without coffee, cocoa, or a sweetened drink mix.
With six children and a homeschool morning to work around, I appreciate a recipe that uses something already cooked. A small portion of plain pumpkin can go into a mug-sized batch instead of becoming another baking project. This one needs your attention at the stove, but the measuring and blending happen before you start heating.
Choose Soft, Plain Cooked Pumpkin
Measure one-quarter cup of soft, cooked pumpkin. It should mash easily under a fork, with no firm pieces or tough skin. Plain cooked butternut squash or another winter squash can take the same place in this recipe.
Have the pumpkin cool before it goes into the Ninja with the eggs. Keep the preparation plain. A sweetened pumpkin pie filling brings its own sugar, spices, and sometimes starch, which would change the measured drink.
The quarter cup is enough to give the eggnog a light orange-gold color and a gentle pumpkin flavor. It is not supposed to become a thick pumpkin purée in a mug. The water and eggs are part of the balance, so keep their amounts unchanged when choosing pumpkin or squash.
Coconut Butter Makes the Base
The two teaspoons of homemade coconut butter are whole coconut ground into a smooth paste. This is the ingredient also called coconut cream concentrate. It is different from coconut oil and from liquid coconut cream.
Coconut oil contains the separated fat. Coconut butter includes the ground coconut flesh as well. You need that whole-coconut ingredient with the measured three-quarter cup of filtered water here; oil alone will not make the same base.
If the coconut butter has firmed, gently soften it enough to measure, then let it cool before blending. Stir through any separated coconut oil in its jar first. Scoop the two teaspoons from the mixed butter rather than measuring only the oil layer.
This version does not call for an extra cup of coconut milk. The water and coconut butter already supply its base. For a warm drink using finished homemade milk instead, the Hot Coconut Milk Eggnog With Vanilla has its own complete recipe.
Vanilla, Honey, and Pumpkin Spice
Use one teaspoon of homemade vanilla extract and one-half teaspoon of plain pumpkin pie spice. Check that a packaged spice blend contains only spices, without sugar, starch, or other additives.
The spice should smell warm and fragrant before it goes into the drink. In the finished eggnog, fine brown flecks are normal. The spice belongs throughout the drink, so each sip has the same flavor.
Sweeten with raw honey to taste. Begin with a little, then adjust once the eggs are cooked. Pumpkin and winter squash vary in sweetness, so there is no single required honey amount in the card.
Decide on the Optional Additions
One tablespoon of plain, unflavored bovine gelatin makes the drink fuller and gives it a firmer set when cold. It is optional. Leave it out when you want a looser warm eggnog, and do not replace it with collagen peptides expecting the same thickening.
The optional tablespoon of homemade ghee adds a buttery flavor. The optional tablespoon of coconut oil adds coconut richness. Either can be omitted, and leaving out the ghee gives you the dairy-free version.
Start with the richness you enjoy. The eggs and pumpkin already give the drink body, while the optional additions make that same base fuller.
Blend Before the Pan Gets Hot
Put the two eggs, cooked pumpkin, coconut butter, and water into the Ninja BN801. Blend until the pumpkin is completely worked through and the mixture has one pale orange color. There should be no separate yolk streaks or visible squash pieces.
Pour into a small stainless saucepan. Whisk in the vanilla, pumpkin pie spice, honey, and optional gelatin while the mixture is still cool. Sprinkle gelatin across the surface so it gets wet instead of collecting in one dry mound.
The mixture should move easily around the whisk. Fine spice flecks will remain, but dense coconut-butter lumps or orange pieces of pumpkin mean the cold blend needed more work. Smooth the base before heating, when the blender can do its job without hot liquid.
Heat to 160°F Without Boiling
Warm over medium heat and whisk frequently across the bottom and sides. The pumpkin aroma will become more noticeable with the vanilla and spice as steam starts to rise. The liquid should stay smooth as it warms.
Check the stirred drink with a food thermometer and remove the pan at 160°F. Do not wait for boiling bubbles. Heat that is too strong can set the eggs into small curds rather than keeping them evenly mixed through the drink.
If the edge heats quickly, lower the burner and keep the whisk reaching that edge. There is no fixed heating time to guess here. The starting temperature and your pan affect the time; the thermometer gives you the stopping point.
Finish While It Is Warm and Pourable
Off the heat, whisk in the optional ghee and coconut oil as they melt. Whisk vigorously until the drink is uniform, without a separate slick of fat. The used whisk should have a light coating of the orange-gold mixture on its wires.
Pour into a roomy heat-safe mug and serve warm. There is no separate topping in this recipe. Its pumpkin flavor and spice are already blended through, and the finished texture should pour rather than sit in a stiff mound.
Where It Fits on Full GAPS
Make this on Full GAPS after the eggs, coconut, cooked squash, honey, spices, and optional additions are introduced and tolerated. It is not an Introduction Diet drink, even though cooked squash and eggs appear earlier in the wider GAPS progression.
Coconut butter brings whole-coconut fiber into the mug, and the complete drink also includes vanilla and pumpkin spice. Those additions are part of its Full GAPS placement.
For dairy-free, omit the ghee. For a lighter texture, omit the gelatin or optional fats. These are choices within this Full GAPS recipe; they do not create an earlier Intro version.
Serving and Storage
The batch makes one serving. Use a heat-safe mug with room for the pumpkin, eggs, water, and additions together. A 16-ounce mug gives you useful space at the rim instead of forcing the drink into a small cup.
Prepare the plain cooked pumpkin ahead and keep it refrigerated until needed. You can also have the coconut butter and vanilla ready in the cupboard. Blend and heat the eggnog close to when you want to drink it.
Refrigerate leftovers promptly in a covered container. Gelatin and coconut fat can make the cold drink much firmer. Rewarm gently on the stove while stirring until it flows again, without boiling or using the microwave.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I Use Butternut Squash?
Yes. Use the same quarter cup of soft, cooked butternut or winter squash. Keep it plain and blend it smooth. The color and sweetness will vary with the squash, so adjust the honey to taste after cooking.
Is Coconut Cream the Same as Coconut Butter?
No. This recipe needs whole coconut butter, also called coconut cream concentrate, with its separately measured water. Liquid coconut cream already contains water and has a different balance. Use the linked homemade coconut butter recipe.
Can I Make It Without Gelatin?
Yes. The pumpkin and whole eggs still give the warm drink body. Without gelatin it will be looser, particularly after cooling. Leave the rest of the recipe unchanged.
What if the Eggs Form Little Curds?
Remove the pan from the heat. Cool the mixture fully before smoothing it in the Ninja, then rewarm gently on the stove. Do not blend hot liquid in the BN801. Stopping the first heat at 160°F helps prevent this problem.
Recommended Equipment
The Ninja BN801 handles the cool pumpkin-and-egg blend. Use a small Le Creuset stainless saucepan, a stainless whisk that reaches its lower edges, measuring tools, a food thermometer, and a heat-safe mug. The whisk handles the warm fat additions after the saucepan comes off the heat.
More Warm Homemade Drinks
For an adult coffee-and-cocoa option, Warm Mocha Eggnog has its own measured milk-and-coffee base and occasional later Full GAPS placement.
Try Hot Coconut Milk Eggnog With Vanilla when you want the same warm eggnog idea without pumpkin. For an occasional cocoa option later on Full GAPS, Pumpkin Hot Cocoa has a different flavor and its own GAPS placement.
The planned Drinks Cookbook will collect more measured homemade drinks in one place. Check the WFLI shop for availability and other kitchen resources.
Hot Pumpkin Spice Eggnog Recipe
Hot Pumpkin Spice Eggnog for Full GAPS
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- Blend the whole eggs, cool cooked pumpkin, homemade coconut butter and water in the Ninja BN801 until uniformly pale orange with no yolk streaks or pumpkin pieces.
- Pour into a small stainless saucepan. Whisk in homemade vanilla, pumpkin pie spice, honey to taste and optional gelatin. Sprinkle the gelatin across the cool surface and whisk until it is wet and distributed.
- Heat over medium heat, whisking frequently along the bottom and sides. Check the stirred mixture with a food thermometer and remove the pan at 160°F. Do not boil, which can curdle the eggs.
- Off the heat, add the optional ghee and coconut oil. Whisk vigorously as they melt until smooth and even, without a separate oil layer. Keep the hot mixture out of the Ninja.
- Pour into heat-safe mugs and serve warm while the eggnog flows easily.
Notes
Tried this recipe?
Let us know how it was!
Leave a comment