Hot coconut milk eggnog is a warm, softly spiced drink made with two whole eggs and one cup of homemade coconut milk. Vanilla and cinnamon flavor the pan, then a little nutmeg goes on the mug. The eggs give it body without flour or starch. You can keep it light or add the optional gelatin and fats for a richer finish.
I work second shift and homeschool before work, so breakfast has to fit into a morning that already has plenty happening. A one-person recipe is useful when you want something warm without making a whole holiday pitcher. Measure the ingredients first, stay beside the saucepan while it heats, and pour when the mixture is smooth.
Start With Homemade Coconut Milk
Use one cup of Hot-Water Homemade Coconut Milk, cooled before it goes into the blender with the eggs. Stir the milk first if its coconut fat has risen to the top. You want the measured cup to contain both the creamy part and the liquid underneath.
The milk is a finished ingredient here. Make and strain it before you begin the eggnog, rather than putting shredded coconut straight into this drink. That keeps the warm egg mixture smooth and avoids little fibrous pieces in each sip.
The coconut gives the drink a gentle coconut flavor. Cinnamon and vanilla soften that flavor, while the eggs make the color warmer and the texture fuller. This is still a drink you pour into a mug, not a bowl of thick custard.
Choose Your Sweetness and Richness
Use raw honey to taste. Two teaspoons is a useful starting point for this one-serving batch, then you can adjust the sweetness when the eggs are cooked. A strongly flavored honey will come through more than a mild one. The card leaves the amount as “to taste” because there is no single required sweetness.
Measure one teaspoon of homemade vanilla extract. It adds the familiar vanilla smell without a sweetened flavoring or syrup. Use the quarter teaspoon of plain cinnamon in the pan, then reserve the nutmeg for the finished mug.
Plain, unflavored bovine gelatin is optional. The measured tablespoon gives the drink more body and will make it much firmer if it cools. It is gelatin, not collagen peptides. Peptides do not have the same setting action.
The optional tablespoon of homemade ghee brings a buttery finish. A tablespoon of coconut oil gives more coconut richness. You can omit either or both. Leave out the ghee when you need a dairy-free version, and keep the coconut milk and two eggs unchanged.
Blend the Cold Milk and Eggs
Put the cooled coconut milk and two whole eggs in the Ninja BN801. Secure the lid and blend just until you cannot see separate yolk or egg-white streaks. There is no need to build a thick head of foam.
Pour the blended mixture into a small stainless saucepan. The cold blend is what distributes the eggs before heat reaches them. Whisk in the cinnamon, vanilla, honey, and optional gelatin while the mixture is still cool.
Sprinkle the gelatin over the liquid rather than dumping it into one dry mound. Keep whisking so the granules get wet throughout the mixture. Scrape the lower edge of the pan with the whisk, where small pockets of honey or powder can collect.
Warm Gently and Stop at 160°F
Set the saucepan over medium heat and whisk frequently, reaching the bottom and sides. As the drink warms, it becomes pale custard-gold with fine cinnamon speckles. The vanilla and cinnamon should smell warm and clear, without a scorched smell.
Use a food thermometer to check for 160°F in the stirred liquid. Remove the pan at that point. Do not wait for a rolling boil. Boiling can make the eggs separate into little curds, and bubbles are not the cue you want for this drink.
Turn down the heat if the edges are heating much faster than the middle. Moving the whisk around the pan distributes that heat. A smooth surface is useful to watch, but the thermometer tells you when to stop; color alone does not measure temperature.
Whisk in the Optional Fats
Take the saucepan off the heat. Add the optional ghee and coconut oil and whisk vigorously as they melt. Work until the drink looks even, without a separate oily ring on top. The whisk should come out lightly coated in eggnog.
This warm finish uses a whisk, so hot eggnog does not go back into the Ninja. Pour into a heat-safe mug and sprinkle a little nutmeg over the top. Its aroma will be strongest near the rim as you lift the mug.
Where This Eggnog Fits on GAPS
This is a Full GAPS drink after whole eggs, homemade coconut milk, honey, spices, and any optional additions have been introduced and tolerated. It is not an Introduction Diet recipe. Removing the gelatin or ghee does not move the coconut-and-whole-egg drink into an earlier Intro stage.
Honey is the sweetener here, rather than stevia, maple syrup, or a flavored coffee syrup. Homemade coconut milk keeps the base free of the gums, starches, and sweeteners that can be added to packaged drinks.
For a cold drink with a different texture, the Light Coconut Milk Eggnog has a short blend and a soft foam cap. The richer coconut milk eggnog makes a larger chilled batch with yolks. Each has its own measured recipe and preparation method.
Serving and Storage
Serve the eggnog warm while it pours easily. The batch is one serving, so a roomy 16-ounce heat-safe mug works better than a small coffee cup. The milk, eggs, and optional additions all contribute to the final volume.
Make the coconut milk ahead and keep it refrigerated if you want less preparation in the morning. The eggnog itself is easiest to make close to serving. Refrigerate anything you do not drink promptly in a covered container.
Gelatin can turn refrigerated leftovers into a soft set rather than a pourable drink. Rewarm gently on the stove while stirring until the mixture flows again. Do not boil it, and do not use the microwave. Coconut fat can also firm when cold, so stir it back through as it melts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I Need the Gelatin?
No. The eggs still give the warm drink body without it. The optional tablespoon makes the eggnog thicker and more likely to set when chilled. Choose the lighter version if you want a looser drink.
Can I Leave Out the Ghee?
Yes. Ghee and coconut oil are separate optional additions. Keep the same milk, eggs, cinnamon, vanilla, and honey. For a dairy-free cup, omit the ghee instead of replacing it with more coconut oil.
Why Did My Eggnog Become Grainy?
The eggs can form curds when the pan gets too hot. Stop at 160°F and keep the whisk moving along the base. If a batch has already separated, take it off the heat and cool it fully before using the Ninja to smooth it. Never put hot liquid into the BN801. Rewarm the smoothed drink gently on the stove.
Can I Use Only Yolks?
This recipe uses two whole eggs. For a yolk-based drink, use the separate Homemade Coconut Milk Eggnog. Leaving out the whites here changes both the volume and the texture.
How Long Does It Take to Heat?
That depends on the starting temperature, saucepan, and burner. Follow the 160°F endpoint instead of guessing a fixed number of minutes. Have your mug and nutmeg ready before heating so you can remove and serve the drink when it is ready.
Recommended Equipment
I use the Ninja BN801 for the cold egg-and-milk blend. A small Le Creuset stainless saucepan, stainless whisk, measuring cup and spoons, food thermometer, and heat-safe mug handle the rest. The whisk needs to reach the pan’s bottom; an oversized whisk in a tiny pan makes that harder.
More Homemade Drinks
For a warm cup with cooked squash and a coconut-butter base, try Hot Pumpkin Spice Eggnog. The Warm Mocha Eggnog adds coffee and cocoa for occasional adult use later on Full GAPS, after digestive symptoms have gone.
If homemade milk is becoming part of your kitchen routine, the planned Drinks Cookbook will collect more measured homemade drinks in one place. Check the WFLI shop for its availability and other kitchen resources. This recipe is one warm cup; the linked cold eggnogs above are useful when you need a larger pitcher.
Hot Coconut Milk Eggnog Recipe
Hot Coconut Milk Eggnog With Vanilla for Full GAPS
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- Blend the cooled coconut milk and whole eggs in the Ninja BN801 just until smooth, with no separate yolk or egg-white streaks.
- Pour into a small stainless saucepan. Whisk in cinnamon, homemade vanilla, honey to taste and optional gelatin. Sprinkle gelatin over the cool liquid rather than leaving a dry mound; whisk until the granules are wet and distributed.
- Heat over medium heat while whisking frequently along the bottom and sides. Check the stirred liquid with a thermometer and remove the pan at 160°F. Do not boil; excessive heat can make the eggs curdle.
- Off the heat, add the optional ghee and coconut oil. Whisk vigorously as they melt until the mixture looks smooth and even, without a separate oily ring. Do not put the hot mixture into the Ninja.
- Pour into heat-safe mugs and sprinkle a little nutmeg on each. Serve warm while the drink flows easily.
Notes
Tried this recipe?
Let us know how it was!
Leave a comment