GAPS treats persistent food cravings as part of the gut problem it asks you to address. In her “Food Addictions” chapter, Dr. Natasha Campbell-McBride connects the pull toward sugar, flour and other processed carbohydrates with the microbes that thrive on those foods. Her practical message is to understand the pattern, eat nourishing GAPS meals and ask the people close to you for useful support.[1]
What GAPS Means by Food Addiction
The chapter describes more than enjoying a favorite food. It discusses an insistent, repeating desire for processed carbohydrates, even when the person knows those foods do not fit the protocol. Dr. Natasha’s explanation is that gut microbes feed on these foods and produce substances, including opiate- and endorphin-like chemicals, that reinforce the desire to eat them again.[1]
Her 2021 presentation calls the wider pattern an “addictive personality” and says it occurs to different degrees throughout the population she describes as having GAPS. It asks parents to understand the food-addiction pattern themselves so they can help a child.[2]
Recognizing a Craving
Dr. Natasha suggests pausing when you want a food you know is outside the protocol. Ask whether the desire reflects your nutritional needs or the microbes demanding their preferred food. The book also describes the familiar reasons that can make an exception sound reasonable: a birthday, a difficult day or not wanting to offend a host. Its purpose is to help you recognize a repeating pattern before acting on it.[1]
Elsewhere, the book describes a “Protein Type” with low tolerance for sugar and carbohydrates, but it also warns that processed-carbohydrate addiction can mislead someone into identifying as a “Carbo Type.” Most people do not fit either extreme neatly, and the chapter says metabolic-typing systems have limitations. A strong desire for processed carbohydrates is not, by itself, a dependable way to choose a metabolic type.[3]
The Substitution Trap
The chapter includes Katrina’s account of replacing sugar and starchy foods with large amounts of fruit and honey. She thought the replacement must be helpful because fruit was supposed to be good for her. Looking back, she describes that substitution as keeping her off course. Dr. Natasha uses the letter to show why changing the ingredient is not always enough to change the eating pattern.[1]
Fruit and honey still have their own place on GAPS. Their stage, amount and the overall pattern of meals matter. My sugar and chocolate cravings guide explains the sweet-food limits, fat-rich meals and the book’s two temporary mixture instructions in one place.
When Binge Eating Needs a Different Starting Route
The author’s FAQ gives a distinct answer for compulsive binge eating without purging that is not improving on Intro. She recommends starting with Full GAPS because it gives a wider choice of foods. Her answer calls for meals high in fat and meat or eggs, meals that are very satisfying, and eating as often as the person wants. She connects the bingeing with nutritional deficiencies, generally protein and fat, and describes resolving those deficiencies as the goal.[4]
For that particular situation, the FAQ describes raw butter or virgin coconut oil mixed with honey to taste, carried in a glass jar, with 1–2 tablespoons about every 20 minutes through the day. This is the binge-eating answer’s amount and interval. It is separate from the two general sugar-craving instructions in the 2020 book. Ingredient tolerance and the wider dietary route still matter.[4][5]
If you are comparing starting routes, read my Intro versus Full GAPS guide before treating a more restrictive menu as the next step. The source’s Full-first answer belongs with its specific binge-eating question.
Learning From a Slip
Katrina’s letter also describes how long it took her to recognize the cost of the foods she kept returning to. She compares two minutes of eating cake with five days of discomfort afterward. That is her reported experience. The useful question for your own notes is what happened after a food, rather than whether you can explain away one more exception.[1]
Keep a brief, ordinary record of the food, the situation and the symptoms you actually noticed. The record should help you spot a pattern you can discuss and plan around. It does not identify a microbe or turn every difficult day into proof that one ingredient caused it.
Making Support Practical
The book specifically asks you to explain the food-addiction pattern to family and friends so they do not undermine the effort unintentionally. It describes understanding support as invaluable.[1] You can make that request concrete: tell a host which foods you can eat, offer to bring a dish and ask relatives to check ingredients with you before handing out a snack.
When my family started GAPS in July 2024, we moved the non-GAPS foods out of the house. There was nothing left to reach for, and we had no slip-ups in the first three months. The timing helped too: we began over the summer while my husband and I were both on leave. Those circumstances helped us organize the change.
A Question About Gatherings
What Can I Do Before a Family Gathering?
For gatherings, my family may eat before going or bring food everyone can eat. A prepared meal gives you something specific to offer when the host asks what would help. My GAPS meals and family-life guide includes the household side of planning food for children and outings.
Your Next Step
Look at one recurring food situation and decide what would make the next meal easier: food ready to eat, an appropriate ingredient swap or a clear request to another adult. My GAPS Food Swap Guide is listed in the WFLI Shop. For the practical craving method, use the sugar and chocolate cravings guide. The separate childhood sugar-craving article explains the book’s child-specific argument, and the satisfaction-after-eating guide covers the meal signal it asks you to notice.
References
- Campbell-McBride, N. Gut and Physiology Syndrome (2020), “Food Addictions,” including Katrina’s letter and family support.
- Campbell-McBride, N. The Full Spectrum of GAPS (2021), “Food Addiction” and “Addictive Personality Forms,” PDF page 7.
- Campbell-McBride, N. Gut and Physiology Syndrome (2020), metabolic types and their limitations.
- Campbell-McBride, N. GAPS FAQs, “Addictions,” question 2, compulsive binge eating without purging.
- Campbell-McBride, N. Gut and Physiology Syndrome (2020), “Implementing the GAPS Introduction Diet,” “Dairy Introduction Structure” and “Sugar Cravings, Chocolate Cravings.”
Leave a comment